Blog

Paper Source paid executives $1.47 million in bonuses while going bankrupt

What a crazy chain of events. This isn’t the same Paper Source I remember discovering as a college student, marveling at the variety of paper options in a charming Chicago store. But first, let’s look at how things unraveled.

A timeline of Paper Source’s shocking history

  1. March 2, 2020: Paper Source buys 30 Papyrus stores.
  2. March 2020: The pandemic hit.
  3. 2020: The top seven executives of Paper Source were paid a combined $1.47 million in bonuses ($640,000 of the bonuses went to the CEO). In addition to the bonuses, the CEO was paid a $552,000 annual salary.
  4. January & February 2021: Paper Source places unusually large orders from their greeting card vendors.
  5. March 2, 2021: Paper Source files for bankruptcy. (When you file for bankruptcy, you don’t have to pay your vendors. All money owed is canceled.)
  6. 2021: As soon as they filed for bankruptcy, the executives proposed that they pay their top 7 executives another $1 million in bonuses.
  7. May 11, 2021: Barnes & Noble buys Paper Source (actually, Hedge fund Elliott Management owns Barnes & Noble).
  8. February 13, 2025: Paper Source announced they will lay off 107 employees at its Forest Park warehouse by April 1.

Today, Paper Source has 117 stores across 28 states, while Barnes & Noble operates more than 600 bookstores. It’s hard to believe how massive they’ve become, considering how corrupt and mishandled the company has been.

My memories of the old Paper Source

It wasn’t always like this. My introduction to Paper Source was a completely different experience.

Image via Google Maps Streetview, April 2009

I have good memories of the store Paper Source. It had only one location, housed in an old corner building in Chicago with three floors of paper goodness. You entered the building under a large Queen Anne-style ornate, cylindrical turret. At the street level were Romanesque heavy, rounded arches with robust masonry. The building conveyed a sense of grandeur and permanence.

Inside, you were greeted with rolls and rolls of paper. In the back were packs of cut paper in 8.5×11 packs. The additional floors had paper crafting supplies like a variety of rubber stamps, cutting and folding tools, and printmaking supplies. It was really geared around makers and artists. There were always customers in the store. Paper Source always had a certain vibe that no other store had.

Back in the early 1990s, it was harder to find interesting sheets of paper. The only other source was generic office supply stores that sold ugly paper. Paper Source had a wide, rich variety of paper that made designing print items for college design classes a lot of fun.

The company was founded in 1983. In college, my design professor, Sherri McElroy, recommended Paper Source to us. So, I made my first visit in about 1994. At that time, the store was just 11 years old.

Inspired by Paper Source

When I was hired by Tribune Media Services’ marketing department in 2000, we would often spec custom paper from paper reps. We grew our paper collection to an entire four-drawer lateral file. As the young designer on staff with a love for paper, I was tasked with organizing all our paper samples.

My original inspiration was always Paper Source.

It wasn’t until 2011 that Paper Source opened a second location (in west suburban Naperville, Illinois). In 2015, we used the Paper Source in Oak Park, Illinois, to research papers for our wedding invites. Ultimately, the cost was too much, so I bought from a vendor online. I don’t think I’ve been to a Paper Source since 2015.

A shocking fall from grace

Today, I cannot fathom how Paper Source is so huge. And how corrupt it has gotten.

It’s shocking to see how far Paper Source has fallen from the charming, innovative store I once knew. The once inspiring source of creativity is now part of a much larger, more complicated corporate story.

Sources

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
oldest
newest most voted