Blog

Feeling less lonely on the web

Every so often, I come across a post that reminds me why I started blogging in the first place. Not because it’s flashy or viral, but because it feels like the early web — people writing, linking, and thinking out loud together. Jay Hoffman’s recent article, Feeling Less Lonely on the Web, did exactly that for me.

Why I started blogging

I’ve been blogging since 2001. I think part of the excitement of blogging since then was due to a few things:

  1. The notion of self-publishing. I grew up in the 80s and 90s when making zines was totally cool. I loved making my own little publications and comic books. Then the web made it even easier to have a larger audience.
  2. Google visibility. When I first started blogging in the early 2000s Google/Yahoo ranked my site high, thus tens of thousands of people coming to my site every month.
  3. Conversations in the comments. The people coming to my site would comment, because back then, people would comment on blogs. There wasn’t social media. The comments was a fun motivation for me to keep writing.
  4. Changes the way you view things. When you have a blog, you view things in a different light. You are always looking for a new topic.

And now, since about 2012 or so, the traffic has died off a good amount. But I continue to write. Mostly because I love sharing ideas. I have the hope that someone might discover something interesting that I’ve written. But I also write, so I have an archive of who I am.

Interlinking blogs

The points left by other people in this Jay’s article are fantastic. Like this one by Manu, Blogs don’t need to be so lonely:

I think we have all the tools we need to address the issue Jay’s flagging in his post. Now we just need to actually do it. I think it comes down to linking more to what other people are writing, posting more replies to other people’s posts, and putting some effort into connecting directly with the author when we stumble on a piece of writing that resonates with us.

Manu’s point of linking to other people’s writings. Yeah! Totally. Somehow, it seems blogs these days don’t do as much interlinking. Why? Maybe because people think the interlinking job is better done on social media, so then why bother linking inside the blog post. That’s kinda silly.

Hence, I’m writing this blog post now, and linking to other people’s writings. That idea of connection naturally leads to something else I’ve been thinking about—writing together.

Collaborative blogs

Jay quotes Tracy Durnell about collaborative blogs

To participate in a collaborative blog, I personally would want a theme and some shared goal / outlook / understanding that gave it purpose and differentiated it from my personal blog.

The collaborative blog concept is really good — bringing people together. I think that has been mostly solved by Reddit. That site/service is just amazing in how it works with all its subreddits and moderators. You have every niche possible. All populated with people who actively comment. The up- and down-voting system helps to bring the best content in each subreddit to the top. It really works well. I find I spend more of my time on there, because I can directly connect with people in specific niches.

Jay touches on this notion of centralization in “Do blogs need to be so lonely?” (bolding mine)

Modern blogging is built on top of a techno-individualistic mindset. It’s something that requires one to teach themselves a set of technical skills, preventing it from being a more communal pursuit. This is especially true in the current era of the web, when centralized platforms absorbed most of the web’s content, and only left space for individuals with time on their hands.

Yeah, it is a shame, in a way that all these social media platforms have taken away from the indy experience online. I still love to write on my own blog, but so many have stopped. I would love to hear from all those voices that have stopped writing.

As far as contributing to a collaborative blog, just speaking from my own personal experience…. I know I should have done this more when collaborative blogs were a thing in the early 2000s. (like 2003 to 2016). I use those specific dates, because I think of Gapers Block in Chicago. Lots of people contributed to that site. I loved that site. I never specifically contributed, because they would simply link to my site when I wrote something interesting.

However, in this age, collaborative blogs may be a good way to bring people together.

If I ever took the time to write a longer post that I share on one of these collaborative blogs, I would also want to post that on my own site, just for the sake of archives. I’ve seen too many platforms go down and lose everything. In fact, when I was actively engaged on the subreddit r/BeatTheStreak this year, I would often post there. But I would also copy my comment and put it on my baseball blog, 57hits.com.

The nature of comments

In the comments section of Jay’s post, a fascinating comment was left by Dan Q:

I read a lot of blogs, but it always saddens me when I find one with no comments capability. I get it, I really do: spam is a big problem and it’s hard to mitigate.

But comments aren’t just about getting in touch with the author, so you can’t just replace them with an “email me” link and call it the same thing. They’re about communicating with other readers of the post. Getting a feel for the wider bubble. And, thanks to backlinks and Trackbacks and Pingbacks and Webmentions and ActivityPub, discovering other bloggers just outside your current horizon.

The humble comments form may the simplest universal way to achieve all of the above. They’re not perfect. But they’re good enough, and I’m pleased to see them starting to make a comeback.

What a great point! Comments aren’t just for the author. They are for the reader. And comments are not just extended points in the original post. Comments give you the vibe of the other readers. This is brilliant.

Jay writes:

I still plan on tracing a more complete history of comments, but as a rough outline, they were pushed to the bottom of the page by the early 2000’s. By the 2010’s, they started falling off completely, inundated with neglected spam and flame wars. This made them pretty easy to turn off, which a lot of sites did. And some of that natural participation of the web fell off too.

First off, I’m eager to read Jay’s comprehensive history of comments. I’ve long contemplated the nature of comments on my media blog.

What Facebook ABSOLUTELY got correct with comments was putting the comment form right on the homepage. Not just one comment box. But every single post had a comment form on the homepage. There’s no clicking into the post to leave a comment. You just started typing into the box.

These days on Facebook, you have to click a “comment” button. But that doesn’t even open a new page, it just opens a module. You effectively stay in the stream. There’s no leaving the stream. Comment generation continues to be in-stream on Facebook—to this very day.

There is a connection between design and participation. Design can lower friction for engagement.

I don’t understand why blogs don’t follow this. Almost every blog, you need to go to the full blog post. You can’t just leave a comment right away on the homepage. I’m guilty of this. I never bothered programming this functionality into my site. (To be fair, about 15 years ago I would have not known how to do this. However, I now have the programming knowledge to implement this. But now it just feels too late. People simply don’t comment on blog posts. The general consensus is that social media is the place to leave comments.)

Blog archives open for commenting

Another thing social media gets right about comments is leaving them open to be commented on, years after the post was published.

Many sites disable commenting on posts after a certain period of time. I get the idea. There are comment trolls out there who will comment spam posts, even old posts.

However, I absolutely love keeping old posts open for comments. It’s like reading a book from 20 years ago, and talking about it with someone. That book, published 20 years ago, remains relevant today.

When Twitter was a normal site, I had a bookmarklet that would look at tweets made 10 years ago by people I followed. I would often reply to old tweets. There’s something about the magic of an archive that can continue to bring forth dialogue and new ideas.

Yup

Maybe that’s the way forward—just writing, linking, and keeping the conversation going. If this post resonates, I’d love to hear from you—on your blog, in your comments, wherever your corner of the web lives.

Here’s a list of the posts linked in my post:

The web still feels lonely sometimes, but maybe it doesn’t have to be. Every link, every comment, every post we write is a small act of connection — a signal that we’re still here, thinking and sharing. I’ll keep doing that, and I hope others will too. Write something. Link to someone. Leave a comment. Keep the conversation alive.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

6 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Jay Hoffmann
1 year ago

Glad you enjoyed my post! Happy to say that I’m putting some finishing touches on my history of comments posts, so that’s coming up soon.

Leozito
1 year ago
Reply to  Jay Hoffmann

Eu tbm estarei aguardando por isso.

Leozito
1 year ago

achei muito interessante, eu ja estava tentando implementar webmentions nos meus posts e consegui hj! Mas… depois de ler seu blog me deu vontade de implementar uma sessão de comentarios tbm, para deixar mais facil das pessoas colaborarem. Obrigado por isso

Safwaan Mohammad
Safwaan Mohammad
11 months ago

i very much agree with your ideas! Blogs can make a comeback especially with how social media has degenerated into a mess of political outrage, sexual content, and brainrot. Blogs make us remember a time when content online actually meant something and wasn’t written to stoke outrage.