Social Media

Rent or Buy in Chicago?

Everyone seems to be buying in Chicago. It’s THE thing to do. The New York Times released one of the coolest web apps ever called “Is It Better to Rent or Buy?” Just plug in your numbers and POW, it tells you if it’s better to rent or buy.

And boy, do I ever learn the critical importance of Annual home price appreciation. Here’s the graph with a 5% increase.

Oh wow. 11 years, it’s better to buy. Sounds great, right?

Well, let’s take a look at a 3% annual home price appreciation:

OUCH! It’s better to rent, like, forever!

Now how did I get that 4% number for the rate of increase for renting. From 1988-1997 Chicago’s rent increase was 4.0%. But that’s ten years ago. The average rent nationwide was 2.5% in 2005. (And in 2004 the apartment vacancy rate was 10.4%, the highest level since the Census Bureau began keeping statistics in 1956.) Ok, so putting down 4% for apartment rate increase should be a very liberal amount that favors buying.

Back to annual home price appreciation, buying a house or condo REALLY depends on this annual home price appreciation. What’s the history of this trend? Read below the fold to see more graphs.

Courtesy of Marin Real Estate Bubble blog and National Association of Realtors. Here are some graphs with National trends.

Momma. Look at that dip.

And it looks even WORSE for condos!

Now it makes me wonder if the market will rebound, look at all those years when the appreciation was really high. I all need is a 5%.

But then this graph freaks me out:

People are just overspending what they can afford. I’m convinced that too much of America is in debt, like, serious debt.

Comments are very welcome, please leave a reply

29 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
11 Comment authors
asdMatt MaldreLisa Schryvermasini de inchiriat bucurestiFurniture Store Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest oldest most voted

I don’t know much about real estate. But it looks like the housing market bubble has burst. Now, I’d guess some places are still trying to get top dollar for their townhomes/condos/houses. You don’t want to pay top dollar for a place just as the bubble is bursting. It might be smart to wait for all industry reports to say that housing is clearly on the decline. So wait until it’s a 100% buyers market.… Read more »

Andre Alforque

There is no general rule for this. It depends on where you are in your life, and what you plan to do. If you want to be buying towards a mansion to retire in, you best start buying now. But, if you plan on moving around the country and not settling down, you best stay a renter. And yes, just like any other investment (like playing the market), there are risks. Why worry about your… Read more »

Andre Alforque

Well, picking a CPA is like picking therapist — you have to try them out until you find the one you like. For someone like you that wants more interaction, you may have to spend a little more effort and money in a CPA. Yes, most CPA’s throw out numbers; but there are interactive ones as well. You hire them to give you advice about investments; your level of involvement is up to you. Choose… Read more »

Lisa Schryver
Lisa Schryver

These graphs are useful to a point, however, it doesn’t take into account where you live. Chicago’s home appreciation is quite good, unless of course you live in Englewood or some other neighborhood that no one wants to live in. Also, it depends on your home itself. If it has what everyone wants (typically, good sized kitchen w/ nice appliances, nice baths, outdoor space and parking) then you’ll have no problem gaining a nice return… Read more »

Lisa Schryver
Lisa Schryver

Oh, and renting is like throwing money out the window. When you own, you’re at least earning equity, which is always better in the long run.

Lisa Schryver
Lisa Schryver

Here’s what the financial genius had to say: eh, yes and no. I haven’t had time to really dig into it, but it appears that this could be correct assuming an interest-only mortgage. If you are actually amortizing there are a few other issues to take into account. 1. Equity payments – They start off small (maybe you are paying back $100 a month for the first few years) but by year 15 on a… Read more »